I am trying to find out exactly where Archiebald J McNeil (married Josephine E Dolan) was from and who his parents were/from.
The 1910 census says he was from Scotland Canada & b. 1863
The 1920 census says he was from New Brunswick Canada & b. 1865
The 1930 census says he was from Canada (English)
His tombstone says he was born in 1866
He name has been spelled a few different ways and I have seen it written as "Archie".
According to this index, his naturalization record says he was born 10 June 1863 in Do[r]chester, New Brunswick, Canada.
But the 1881 census for Dorchester says that he was born in Prince Edward Island.
ironically here is a record from Index to New England Naturalization Petitions, 1791-1906 (M1299) that is one year off Chris' post for naturalization.
Thank you Chris and Ben for your replies!